QUESTION:
Dear Rabbi Ali,
I am recently married and I am a bit confused about certain marriage concepts. For example, whenever I tell my husband something about the way that he dresses, he gets so frustrated and it turns into a fight. Aren’t we supposed to be one, which means we’re on the same page on all matters? There are many other examples but they are irrelevant. I’d appreciate some clarity on this concept of being one.
R’ Ali’s Response:
This may seem like the idea of being one is a simple concept. However, this misconception is one of the biggest causes of marital friction. I write and speak about this often. Yes, once we get married we are supposed to become one. Let’s first explain what one does not mean. “One” doesn’t mean that one person dictates how the other should now behave and the other person becomes submissive and completely obliterates their individuality and who they are. That would mean that there is one person here and the other has disappeared.
This reminds me of a joke that I heard from Rabbi Shimon Gruen. Two people got married and someone told them that they will now become one. A while later, they went back to that person and said that they’re confused, which one are they to become? The point is clear – “one” does not mean that you now take the identity of one person.
Every person has their own unique personality and individuality. Everyone has a right to their opinions, thoughts, and tastes. Of course, I’m not talking about dangerous or ridiculous behaviors. If your husband likes gray pants and you don’t, it’s his choice and you should not tell him that he must change, all in the name of being on the same page or of being one. This can manifest itself in multiple ways, well beyond the clothes that he wears. How to raise children becomes a very sensitive topic. People will want the children to be raised a certain way. When their spouse disagrees, they get frustrated and say, “We’re not on the same page.” Really what they’re saying is, “You’re not on my page.”
So, what is this concept of being one that takes place when we get married? “One” means that you are one unit. You are two completely different individuals learning how to work together as a team. There’s no more “you,” there’s “we.” If one spouse doesn’t feel well, “we” have a problem. If one of the two is going through something emotionally or financially, “we” have an issue.
Before marriage, you were the only one who had your own personal struggles and dilemmas. Now that has changed. “One” means that we are now concerned about the unit and not only about ourselves. You wake up in the morning and think about what you both need.
Instead of saying, “I like pizza,” now you say, “ I like pizza and my husband prefers sushi.” Accepting each other’s differences and respecting them is one of the most fundamental concepts of marriage. If this concept is clear, then the stage is set for a healthy marriage. Once the lines get crossed and one person “rules” the relationship, it creates a resentful and frustrated spouse. They might do as you please or demand, but they do so begrudgingly, like a child being coerced by their parents. A husband/wife relationship is much different than the parent/child relationship.
To answer your question, stop giving him orders, especially about the way that he dresses. Believe it or not, if you would approach the situation differently he might even change his clothes. “Hey, I think you look so much better in the white shirt than in the gray one.” Now, he knows which one you prefer, and he just might change to make you happy. This really leads to another point – the more you push someone, the more they don’t want to do as you say.
This is just basic human nature and is not exclusive to men or to women. Try it, you’d be surprised how well your words are taken. Also, your husband will be happy that you mentioned something positive instead of how ridiculous he looks.
This is the way of the Torah. Words that are spoken nicely and gently are received very well. To conclude, it’s important to know that if an issue arises that seems like a halachic or hashkafic issue, a rabbi should be consulted. The ideas I mention here are a basic outline for simple mundane matters.