QUESTION:
Dear Rabbi Ali,
I would say that my marriage is pretty good. I have one area that is the source of tension and would appreciate some insights as to what I can do. My wife does not like going to my parents for Shabbat. She also doesn’t want them coming over. This applies to my whole family as well. She gets upset when I talk to them and says that I’m choosing them over her. I know she has some issues with my father, but nothing that seems to warrant all of this. Is there anything I can do to stay connected with my family while keeping the peace?
R’ Ali’s Response:
Unfortunately, this is very common and I’d like to address a few points that are very relevant to anyone going through this. First, everyone should be aware that when they get married, their spouse should not be cutting ties with their family. Family is extremely important and should be part of people’s lives for many years to come. Family gives stability, and in many cases no friend can replace family. I cannot overemphasize the damage that people do by “boxing out” their spouse from their family. People must realize that although they may have a valid point and feel uncomfortable with their spouse’s family, it’s a grave mistake to write them off.
Additionally, I’ve seen many people talk negatively to their spouse about their family. This causes much pain and resentment. If something bothers you, talk about it like a mature adult. Venting negativity to your spouse about their family is not advised at all.
People have a misconception about married life. Lines such as, “your wife/husband comes first,” get thrown around in the wrong places. There are halachic and hashkafic issues many times and a rabbi should be consulted. Just as an example, if a wife’s father asks her to do something conflicting with the husband’s wishes, the wife must go with the husband. This does not work the other way.
Please do not use this article for any halachic decisions, I’m just pointing out that there are times when “the spouse comes first,” and times that it may not apply.
The question you are asking is what should you do now that your wife is “boxing you out” from your family? For starters, you should always try to communicate how you feel in a nice and non-threatening way. Validating her feelings, but state clearly how you feel. “I know you have a hard time going to my parents and I understand you completely. However, I need to stay connected on a basic level to my family.” Try to find a compromise that works for both of you.
If she has a specific issue with your family members, it would be ideal to attempt to resolve it. This would need professional help in my opinion. Choose a third party that you both respect and trust.
Lastly, it should be clear that not having a connection with your family is not an option. You mention that she gets upset when you even speak with them. Say as gently as possible, “I know you have a problem when I speak with my family, however these relationships are extremely important to me and I must stay connected.”
I would advise to continue speaking with your family and being open with your wife. “I love you and I love them, and I hope we can resolve this as soon as possible.”
As I’ve mentioned, in this case I recommend meeting with a professional, as it is sensitive. Of course, I’m not talking about a situation where there’s an unhealthy relationship with you and your family members, which a professional could determine, as well.
In conclusion, family issues are very delicate and sensitive. All delicate and sensitive issues should be dealt with in a sensitive manner. Many times, the issues are multifaceted and truly are complex. Both parties should understand how important family is, as well as how uncomfortable the other one may feel around certain family members. When people feel understood and that the other person does not think they’re crazy, even complicated situations become much easier to navigate.
I’ve seen so many complicated situations navigated nicely and respectfully, and sadly many simple situations dealt with in a reckless manner, causing unnecessary anguish. Work together, understand each other, and you will see how smooth a complicated situation can be.