51 F
New York
Saturday, October 18, 2025
spot_img
Home Blog Page 25

Egleston Eagles Soar to DFL Super Bowl Victory

Sam Sutton

In an unforgettable clash of grit, determination, and elite football talent, the Egleston Eagles, captained by star wide receiver Michael Panetz, claimed the 2024 DFL Super Bowl title in stunning fashion. They toppled the top-seeded Smooth Mobile Oil Cowboys in a thrilling showdown that ended with a final score of 26-25.

The victory was the culmination of an improbable postseason run that will go down as one of the greatest stories in DFL history. With quarterback Shimi Cohen delivering a career-defining performance on the biggest stage, the Eagles shocked the Cowboys and etched their names in league lore. Cohen’s efforts earned him the coveted Super Bowl MVP honors, cementing his legacy as one of the DFL’s most clutch performers.

A Wild Start Sets the Tone

The game began with fireworks as the Cowboys immediately showcased why they were the #1 seed. On the very first play, star QB Eli Siegal connected with Novoseller on a stunning length-of-the-field touchdown, giving the Cowboys an early 6-0 lead. It was a statement start for the favorites, but the battle-tested Eagles were unfazed.

The Eagles answered swiftly. Cohen orchestrated a picture-perfect drive that culminated in a touchdown and a two-point conversion, putting the Eagles ahead 8-6. The opening sequences set the stage for a back-and-forth battle that kept fans on the edge of their seats.

Trading Blows in the First Half

The Cowboys regained the lead as Eli Siegal, living up to his star billing, powered into the end zone on a rushing touchdown. The Eagles fought back, but the Cowboys’ defensive unit, which had been a cornerstone of their dominance all season, made key stops to maintain control.

At halftime, the Cowboys held a slim 19-14 lead, thanks to Siegal’s dual-threat brilliance. The Eagles, however, had been here before. This was a team built on resilience, and they headed into the locker room confident in their ability to turn the tide.

Second Half Drama Unfolds

The second half began with both teams locked in a defensive stalemate, but midway through, the Eagles delivered a momentum-shifting moment. On 4th and long, Cohen unleashed a deep pass that found Irwin Sutton streaking down the sideline for a jaw-dropping touchdown. The play electrified the Eagles’ sideline and gave them a 20-19 lead, putting the pressure squarely on the Cowboys.

Not to be outdone, the Cowboys showed why they were the top seed. Rookie sensation Mordy Sultan, who had been a revelation all season, hauled in a long touchdown pass to restore the Cowboys’ advantage at 25-20. With time ticking away, the game appeared to be slipping from the Eagles’ grasp.

Michael Panetz Seals the Deal

But the Eagles weren’t finished. With just minutes remaining, their captain and leader, Michael Panetz, stepped up when his team needed him most. Running a perfectly executed route, Panetz hauled in a 40-yard bomb from Cohen for a go-ahead touchdown. The play sent the Eagles ahead 26-25, igniting celebrations on their sideline.

The Cowboys had one final drive to save their season, but the Eagles’ defense rose to the occasion. In a fitting conclusion to their improbable run, the Eagles made a crucial stop, clinching their Super Bowl victory and leaving the Cowboys stunned.

An Improbable Journey

The Eagles’ journey to the championship was nothing short of remarkable. Entering the postseason as underdogs, they defied the odds with a combination of stellar leadership, clutch performances, and unyielding belief. Shimi Cohen’s MVP effort in the Super Bowl epitomized their season-long resilience, while Michael Panetz’s game-winning play demonstrated why he is one of the league’s premier captains.

The Cowboys, despite falling short, showcased why they were the top seed. Eli Siegal and his squad battled valiantly and provided a worthy championship test. Ultimately, the Eagles’ determination proved to be the difference.

Looking Ahead

As the dust settles on the 2024 season, the Egleston Eagles’ championship run will be remembered as one of the greatest in league history. With their core of talent and leadership, the future looks bright for the DFL.

Community Highlights – Coney Island Residents Push Back Against Boardwalk Casino Proposal

On January 9th, Coney Island residents gathered to debate a proposal from a developer that would fundamentally alter the face and function of the People’s Playground.


At a public land use hearing held by Community Board 13 at the Coney Island YMCA, residents and business owners sounded off on the Coney, a project from Brooklyn developer Thor Equities and the Oklahoma-based Chickasaw Nation seeking to transform five acres of the iconic boardwalk into a massive complex housing a casino, a hotel, a convention center, and a music venue.


Clips posted across social media show a loud and heated stand-off at the Y. Advocates seem overwhelmingly pro-business, relishing the thought of year-round foot traffic to their bars, restaurants, and seaside tchotchke shops in an area reliant on seasonal tourism. They also claim the project, per the developer’s plans, would bring thousands of jobs to the area.


Opponents, on the other hand, appear focused on how a project of this scale would affect the day-to-day lives of those who actually live in Coney Island and already work there. The plan reportedly calls for the “demapping” (or effective privatization) of streets along Surf Avenue and the demolition and displacement of many rides and vendor spaces, according to a rendering of the proposal shared by Coney Island USA, a local non-profit arts organization leading the campaign against the proposed casino. “It’s clear to us that this is simply a catastrophic destruction of the entire neighborhood!” they wrote in a statement on Instagram.


The Coney is one of 11 casino proposals currently under review by the New York State Gaming Commission, which is set to approve as many as three casinos by the end of the year. But the proposals are not exactly winning over residents of the targeted neighborhoods.

Last month at Magen David Yeshiva High School, Mrs. Jennifer Cabasso’s Pre-AP Art class put together a coloring book featuring their designs. Mrs. Cabasso delivered the coloring books to the Tel Hashomer Hospital in Israel as Hanukah gifts for the patients to enjoy. MDY is so proud of their students and Mrs. Cabasso for bringing joy to children who need it most!

Mabrouk – February 2025

Births – Baby Boy

Mitchell & Sarah Cohen

Mr. & Mrs. Solomon Sharaby

Alan & Sara Greenstein

Abie & Marcy Ash

Jojo & Jen Sasson

Jack & Sara Haber

Harry & Shelly Hidary

David & Rachel Gindi

Abe & Sari Dushey

Isaac & Susan Dayan

Births – Baby Girl

Jacob & Lori Ayal

Abe & Lorraine Dweck

David & Grace Haddad

Allen & Deborah Shalam

David & Linda Antebi

David & Sylvia Tawil

Allie & Rachel Haber

Aly & Celine Sultan

Sol & Rachel Whaba

Lane & Marie Matalon

Engagements

Jacob Setton to Danielle Elbaum

Norman Esses to Claudia Kraiem

Joe Heaney to Dorette Dayan

Isaac Massry to Shelly Greenstein

Joe Terzi to Sarah Mizrahi

David Samuels to Esther Gindi

Maurice Srour to Nicole Dror

Weddings

Yosef Somekh to Esther Mizrahi

From the Files of the Mitzvah Man Hesed Stories – Don’t Let the Yetzer Hara Stop You from Fulfilling Your Mission

Pnina Souid

“I realized, I needed to start an organization so I could get more hesed done,” said the founder of the Mitzvah Man Organization. So, he took out a small ad in Community Magazine, announcing that volunteers were needed. It listed volunteer job possibilities.

During the first three weeks, calls came in asking if it was true that we would really offer rides to doctors’ appointments or do errands for the sick and elderly – for free. Yes! The callers responded, “Hazak u’baruch!” All the callers wanted to verify the validity of the advertisement. They couldn’t believe that someone would dedicate their time, sometimes for many hours, to doing various hesed activities. What this legit?

Please, I told the callers, I need something to do!

But no one was calling to volunteer. No one was calling requesting hesed, either. I was spending money for the ads without seeing results. I wondered if maybe I should stop trying. Maybe I should go back to being an organization of one. Then, I remembered something that I had read about the yetzer hara. If you are working on a worthwhile project the yetzer hara will put thoughts into your head that very well might cause you to change your mind.

That was it. I was not going to let the yetzer hara win. If I would get one call to help a person in need it would be worth it.

The Ball Gets Rolling

That’s all it took. The calls started coming in both asking for help and offering to volunteer. The first calls to volunteer came from people whose families I helped before. They would say, “You gave my aunt a ride to the doctor. I want to give rides to doctors.” “You put tefillin on my grandfather. I want to do that for someone else.” “You pushed my brother in his wheelchair on Ocean Parkway so that he could enjoy the fresh air. I want to be a companion for someone.”

The first month 40 volunteers signed up. So many more people could be helped! And after that another 20 volunteers a month signed on, and another 40 a month until we had 500 volunteers in the first six months.

I created a one-page form for volunteers to complete. Each volunteer was interviewed, and some I interviewed personally. I explained to potential volunteers that there is no obligation to accept a volunteer assignment. If they were needed, they would receive a text message. If they are able to volunteer, they would text me back for instructions.

Every hesed request came to my cell phone and I would, in turn text the volunteers. This became overwhelming as I was single-handedly managing everything.

Administrative Help Recruited

The first person I hired was assigned to make follow-up calls to the volunteers and the recipients. He sent me a daily email to keep me abreast of exactly what happened.

I continued answering every incoming call to know just what was happening. However, I became so busy that I realized I needed to hire a dispatcher. The dispatcher would text the volunteers. I would send the hesed call to the dispatcher and email the dispatcher with instructions for the volunteers.

We continued to be extremely busy. My computer whiz son-in-law created a program that listed all the volunteers and separated them into different groups, (driving, shopping, cooking, going to a shiva house, etc.). We messaged volunteers according to their specific group.

Calls started coming from low-income families or Holocaust survivors, for basics such as a washing machine, refrigerator, air-conditioner, or clothes for the holidays. I had to fundraise just to pay our few employees, but if there was anything in the account left that would cover the requests for material things, the caller would be asked to fill out a request form and would receive what they needed. A Board of Directors was recruited. They handle the financial decisions. Another employee was hired to take care of the financial paperwork.

We help 10,000-12,000 families a year. Over the last 13 years, the Mitzvah Man Organization has grown from one man who wanted to help people to 3,800 volunteers!

Message from the Mitzvah Man

We all have challenges in life. That’s the yetzer hara sidetracking us, telling us we are foolish. If we beat our yetzer hara that’s a hesed from Hashem.

You don’t have to start an organization. Use your skills and the gifts that Hashem gave you. You can read to a blind person or take a person on errands who does not have a car. If you play a musical instrument, go play for a patient in the hospital. If you have money, be generous with it.

The Ultimate Outsider – How One Man Earned a Supreme Eternal Gift

Rabbi Eli J. Mansour

This month, we find ourselves in the proverbial “dead of winter,” but we are given a small taste of springtime, in the form of Parashat Yitro, which tells the story of Matan Torah, the event which we celebrate in the beautiful, joyous warmth of spring. Indeed, the latter part of this parashah is the portion which we read in the synagogue on Shavuot morning.

However, this story has a prologue which introduces it. Before we read of Gd’s revelation on Mount Sinai and pronouncement of the Ten Commandments, we are first told of Yitro, Moshe’s father-in-law, a former pagan priest, who came to the Sinai desert to join Beneh Yisrael and undergo conversion. Fascinatingly enough, the result of this seemingly unimportant episode is that the Torah portion that tells of the most significant event in human history, Gd’s revelation to give us His body of law, is called “Parashat Yitro.” Since this portion opens with the story of Yitro, and the name “Yitro” is the second word of this parashah, this became its name.

Is this merely a random coincidence, that the name of this most significant portion is “Yitro,” or might there by some deeper meaning and significance behind this name?

We must also note the irony of the fact that this parashah is named after the ultimate outsider – a man from a different country, a former leader of idolatrous cults, who joined Beneh Yisrael just prior to the Revelation. Apparently, his story, what he brought us, is so vital and fundamental that it was chosen as the appropriate introduction to Matan Torah, and to have the portion named after him.

Yitro’s Berachah

The answer to these questions begins with Yitro’s jubilant reaction upon hearing Moshe’s report of the miracles that Gd had performed for Beneh Yisrael – the plagues that befell the Egyptians, the splitting of the sea, the supernatural food and water provided in the desert, and so on. Yitro was overjoyed, and exclaimed, “Baruch Hashem asher hitzil etchem – Blessed is Gd who has saved you!” (18:10).

The Gemara (Sanhedrin 94a) finds it jarring that nobody until Yitro made such a proclamation. It is a source of great shame to Beneh Yisrael, the Gemara comments, that they did not bless Hashem for the miracles He performed for them, but Yitro did.

At first glance, this criticism of Beneh Yisrael strikes us as unfair. Beneh Yisrael sang the beautiful Az Yashir, a song of praise to Gd, following the splitting of the sea, as we read in the

previous parashah (Shemot 15). Why are they criticized for not exclaiming, “Baruch Hashem asher hitzil etchem” like Yitro did, if they actually sang a lengthy song expressing their joy over the miraculous salvation that Gd had wrought?

The Brisker Rav (Rav Yitzchak Zev Soloveitchik, 1886-1959) offered a brilliant answer, based on a halachic analysis of birkat hagomel – the blessing required after being delivered from a situation of peril.

Halachah obligates one to recite this berachah after safely emerging from one of the four following situations: captivity, illness, desert travel, and sea travel. Beneh Yisrael faced all four dangers – having been held as slaves, been dealt brutal blows by their ruthless taskmasters, traversed the sea and journeyed through deserts. Yet, at no point do we find that they recited birkat hagomel to thank Gd for rescuing them from these dangers.

The Brisker Rav explains that when Yitro declared, “Baruch Hashem asher hitzil etchem,” he did so in fulfillment of the obligation of birkat hagomel. Of course, Yitro himself did not endure these travails, and was thus not required to recite birkat hagomel, but he recited this blessing on the people’s behalf. The Shulhan Aruch (Orah Haim 219:4) rules explicitly that one who is required to recite birkat hagomel may fulfill this obligation by having somebody else recite it on his behalf. Let us imagine, for example, a gravely ill patient who has recovered, but still feels too weak to recite an unfamiliar blessing. Such a person may ask his friend to recite birkat hagomel for him, and fulfill the mitzvah by listening attentively to the berachah and answering “amen” (just as we do for the obligation of kiddush, for example).

This is precisely what Yitro did – he recited birkat hagomel on the people’s behalf. The Gemara finds fault in Benei Yisrael for failing to have recited this berachah earlier, and waiting until Yitro came along and recited it for them.

Sharing the Emotional Burden

If, indeed, Yitro’s exclamation was actually a halachic act – reciting birkat hagomel on the people’s behalf – then we can develop this point further to gain insight into Yitro’s unique character.

The Taz (Rav David Segal, d. 1667), one of the most important commentators to the Shulhan Aruch, introduces a vitally important qualification to this halachah, which permits someone to recite birkat hagomel on his fellow’s behalf. He writes that this works only if the person reciting the berachah truly and genuinely experiences the other person’s sense of joy and relief. In order for the rescued individual to fulfill his obligation through another person’s berachah, that other person must share his emotions, his feelings of jubilation over having been rescued from a perilous condition.

If so, then we must conclude that this is how Yitro felt upon hearing of the miracles that Hashem performed for Beneh Yisrael. He felt real exhilaration, as though he himself experienced this deliverance from bondage.

Indeed, the Torah uses an unusual term in describing Yitro’s joyous reaction to the stories of Beneh Yisrael’s salvation – “Vayichad Yitro” (18:9). While the word “vayichad” has been interpreted in several different ways, it seems clear that Yitro experienced a unique level of joy, which the Torah sought to emphasize by using this term. Perhaps, the Torah wishes to convey that Yitro did not merely rejoice, but truly sensed the people’s elation. He had this

unique quality of empathy, genuinely feeling other people’s pain during times of hardship, and other people’s exuberance in times of joy and triumph.

This quality of Yitro is manifest also in the next story told about him.

He observed his son-in-law, Moshe, spending the entire day working very hard, tending to the people as they brought to him their problems and disputes to resolve. Yitro urged Moshe to appoint other judges to work under him, so he would not have to shoulder this burden of responsibility alone. This was not just another instance of the all-too-familiar phenomenon of a father-in-law offering unsolicited advice to his son-in-law… Yitro, true to his nature, felt Moshe’s physical and mental stress as he struggled to guide the people all by himself, and so he stepped in to help.

Yitro thus emerges as a paragon of the quality referred to by our sages as noseh be’ol im havero (Avot 6:6) – literally, “carrying the burden with one’s fellow.” The great rabbis of mussar elaborated at great length on the importance of this quality, of sharing other people’s emotional burdens, genuinely feeling their pain and sorrow, and seeking to alleviate it as though it was one’s own. This quality is not just an important moral imperative – it is an actual prerequisite for Torah commitment. We cannot take upon the obligations of the Torah without first taking upon ourselves the obligation to look out for our fellow in distress, which requires genuinely feeling his pain.

Yitro may have been an outsider, but he brought us precisely what we needed at the exact time we needed it. We could not receive the Torah before first learning from his example of empathy.

The story of Yitro introduces the story of Matan Torah because before we accept the Torah, we must first accept the burdens of our fellow Jews. Their problems must be our problems; their hardships must be our hardships; and their joys must be our joys.

Indeed, when we look at the personalities of great Torah sages, we notice that they are not only outstanding scholars, but also people who shoulder the burden of their fellow Jews. Torah scholars have always been at the forefront of charity and advocacy work, constantly working and exerting immense efforts on behalf of individuals in distress and of the Jewish community as a whole.

It should not surprise us at all that these giants maintained their outstanding standards of scholarship even while devoting a great deal of time and attention to helping people in need – because to the contrary, shouldering the burden of others is a prerequisite for becoming a Torah scholar. It is precisely due to these sages’ outstanding empathy and concern for other people that they were able to achieve greatness in Torah – because this quality is an indispensable prerequisite for Torah devotion.

This insight speaks directly to us, as our brothers and sisters in Israel continue to deal with the pain, loss, and hardships of war. There are so many bereaved parents. There are so many widows and orphans. There are so many wounded soldiers, some with permanent conditions and disabilities. There are so many soldiers dealing with PTSD. There are so many reservists whose families are buckling under the heavy burden of life without a husband, father and breadwinner. So many parents cannot sleep because their son or sons are fighting. So many have had their homes damaged or destroyed.

“Yitroism”

As Torah Jews, we cannot for a second be indifferent to the plight of our brothers and sisters in distress. We religiously-committed Diaspora Jews must be at the forefront of the effort to lend assistance and support, in addition, of course, to our heartfelt prayers. The ABCs of Torah Judaism is “Yitroism,” empathizing with those in need, and this is our duty at this difficult time. Each of us has something to contribute, in terms of financial assistance, advocacy efforts, or logistical support for the organizations who work on behalf of Israelis affected by the war. We must each find the way we can help out and lend a hand to our beloved brothers and sisters in Eretz Yisrael.

May Hashem bless our efforts with success, bring an end to the tragedies and suffering, and send us our long-awaited final redemption, speedily and in our times, amen.

From the Files of the Bet Din

The Case

Lost and Found

Debbie and Joey were married less than a year when they realized that their ketuba was lost. Since Debbie did not remember ever storing her ketuba for safekeeping, the couple decided to review their wedding video to determine who was entrusted with the ketuba. The video indicated that Debbie’s mother had placed the ketuba on a small table at the time of the ceremony and it is very likely that it was left there unattended and was disposed of after the wedding. Although the ketuba was lost, a much more disturbing find was discovered upon study of the video. One of the witnesses of their kiddushin was Joey’s close relative. At this point it was evident that the young rabbi who officiated their wedding was incompetent, as the video showed that he never carefully chose valid witnesses prior to the marriage, but rather randomly picked two people to witness the marriage. Our Bet Din reached out to the rabbi, who admitted that since the witnesses did not object to the appointed role, he assumed that they were not related. With a very embarrassing situation at hand, the couple confidentially reached out to our Bet Din seeking a remedy for their problem. Do they need to remarry? If so, can it be done without a formal ceremony? Are the wedding blessings to be said all over again? Which date is to be written on the new ketuba, the day of their mistaken ceremony or today’s date?

How Should the Bet Din Rule and Why?

Torah Law

According to the ruling of the Shulhan Aruch a man is required to provide his wife with a ketuba at the time of their marriage. The ketuba is a document which details the primary duties a husband is obligated to his wife. It includes a monetary commitment from the husband to be paid to his wife in the event he passes on or in case of divorce. As with all legal documents, it is mandatory that a ketuba is dated accurately. The ketuba is given to the bride, and she customarily transfers it to her mother for safekeeping. If the ketuba is lost, the couple is required to obtain a replacement ketuba prepared by a competent halachic authority.

By Torah law, a man can only effectively betroth a woman in the presence of two valid witnesses. If, however, both witnesses are legally invalid, the marriage is rendered null and void. The overall requirement of a witness is that he may not be a relative of the bride or groom, and the two witnesses may not be related to each other. Additionally, a witness is considered invalid if he is a non-observant Jew. Generally,

all other males of age qualify; however, some restrictions may apply. Since many laws govern the type of family relation that disqualifies a witness, and likewise, what constitutes a non-observant Jew, only a competent halachic authority is to choose the witnesses for a wedding ceremony.

A rabbi officiating a wedding is required to designate two valid witnesses at the time of a betrothal, in order to deliberately exclude all relatives present that are seemingly potential witnesses. In instances in which a rabbi mistakenly designates a witness who is invalid, many halachic authorities disqualify the ceremony. Since two witnesses were already designated, albeit one is invalid, any potential valid witnesses present in the audience are no longer eligible as they were already excluded, and the marriage is rendered null and void. This view is widely accepted and is very effectively used to nullify a marriage in case an illegitimate child is conceived by a woman while she is supposedly married. After retroactively nullifying the marriage on account of an invalid witness, the child conceived from another man during the marriage interim, is not halachically viewed as illegitimate. Hence, the child is permitted to marry within the Jewish community.

Although the above view is widely accepted, nevertheless, numerous halachic authorities differ. Although two witnesses were already designated, since one or more were invalid, their designation is viewed as illegal and unacceptable. Hence, the valid witnesses in the audience that viewed the betrothal can effectively consecrate the marriage. Furthermore, in instances in which the rabbi initiated the appointment of the invalid witnesses and not the groom, some halachic authorities rule that it is not within the rabbi’s jurisdiction to effectively disqualify other potential valid witnesses that are present.

Although witnesses from the audience are not always able to view the transfer of the ring from the groom to the bride as required, nevertheless, the marriage is not necessarily disqualified. Since the ring is seen on the bride’s finger immediately after the groom gave it to her, some view this as sufficient testimony, and the marriage is binding.

In all instances in which a halachic debate exists whether a wedding ceremony was valid, when preforming the ceremony a second time the blessings are not recited. In addition, numerous considerations that are not within the scope of this article restrict reciting the blessings a second time.

In the event an original wedding ceremony is undisputedly disqualified, and a completely new ceremony is performed later, a new ketuba is also required. However, in instances in which an original wedding ceremony’s validity is questionable, legally, a new ketuba need not be written. Even so, it is still preferable to write a new ketuba. This ruling is applicable only if the witnesses that signed the ketuba are valid, otherwise, a new ketuba is always required.

While it is required by law to formally conduct a wedding ceremony in the presence of ten men, it nevertheless suffices to conduct a second ceremony in the presence of two valid witnesses.

Endnotes: Shulhan Aruch Eben Haezer 66:1, 3, Ibid 42:2, Shulhan Aruch Hoshen Mishpat 33, 34, Pithei Teshuva Eben Haezer 42:11, 12, Yabia Omer Eben Haezer 8:3:3-7, Rama Eben Haezer 42 end of 2, Mishpat HaKetuba vol. 7 pg. 524, Shulhan Aruch Eben Haezer 34:4 see Mishpat HaKetuba vol.7 pg. 523.

VERDICT: Newlyweds!!!

Our Bet Din conducted a private wedding ceremony for Debbie and Joey. Since one of the witnesses at their original wedding was invalid, a new betrothal was required. Nevertheless, since according to some halachic authorities their original wedding was satisfactory, we did not recite any blessings at the ceremony we conducted. Although a wedding ceremony typically requires ten men present to partake in the event, in this instance two witnesses present was sufficient. A new ketuba was written with the present date, since the original was signed by the invalid witness and is null and void.

Note: Halachic authorities from over a century ago implemented a system known as a duplicate ketuba. This system is practiced by many prominent Syrian communities worldwide and is used as well by the Chief Rabbinate of Israel. It is also being offered to our community by the Sephardic Heritage Museum and is under our Bet Din’s supervision. For further details, refer to the letter of endorsement in this edition of the magazine.

YOU BE THE JUDGE

Our Big Brother

Alan was the founder and 80 percent shareholder of a successful wholesale corporation. His two younger brothers Stan and Steve were each granted by Alan 10 percent of the company shares, on account of their years of hard work and dedication to the business. After decades of successful partnership, unfortunately, Alan suddenly passed on, and he left his assets and total net worth to his wife and children. Stan and

Steve, now in charge of the company’s financials, reviewed the accounting and detected a withdrawal of one million eight hundred thousand dollars back in 2017. The 1.8-million-dollar withdrawal was recorded by the company’s accounting as a distribution of profits to all respective shareholders. The funds were used to purchase a residential property in a suburban area. Much to the two brothers’ surprise they were listed as 2 percent partners for that purchase, as opposed to their respective 10 percent share. Stan and Steve notified Alan’s wife and children of the obvious error and requested them to correct the paperwork. When Alan’s wife refused to comply, Stan and Steve reached out to our Bet Din. They claimed they each owned an additional 8 percent of the property, as well as its present appreciated value according to their respective shares.

Are the brothers entitled to an additional 8 percent? Are they each eligible to 10 percent of the profits generated from the value appreciated?

How should the Bet Din rule and why?

Ask Jido – January 2025

Dear Jido,

I’ve always tipped waiters, hairdressers, food delivery drivers, and manicurists, of course, understanding that most of these positions do not pay very well and the person is likely living off tips more than salary.

Within the last year or so, however, I have been told in several different ways, some not very subtle, that I should also be tipping the cable company technician who comes out to correct static on the line, the HVAC technician who gives my system an annual checkup, the appliance repair person who fixed my dryer, and, most recently, the plumber who came out to unclog a bathroom sink.

In all of those circumstances, I paid the company in question a significant fee for the service, and the person they sent out was in a company vehicle, wearing a company uniform. I assume they are making a decent salary.

Are we supposed to be tipping everyone who provides any service now? How can I determine who is supposed to be tipped and how much they should get? What if I cannot afford to tip, say, an appliance technician after I’ve already paid his company over $300 for the work he did?

Do I need to explain that I can’t afford to tip them, especially when they are standing around after the job, making small talk, obviously waiting for something from me?

Signed,

A Fed-Up Tipper

Dear Not-a-Penny,

What! Tip the plumber? You gotta be kidding.

What are tips for? To Insure Prompt Service. If the plumber didn’t come right away, you would probably just find someone else.

Consider this: What’s the average minimum wage across America? About $15 per hour. What’s the minimum wage for a job that receives tips?

The Federal Minimum Wage for tipped workers is $2.13 per hour. If that’s all he’s making, I wouldn’t use him.

You are correct. Not everyone should be tipped. But, even if he’s a skilled worker but he did something “over the top” for you, you still might want to give him/her something “for them.” You wouldn’t be setting a precedent and you would actually feel good about it.

But what should you do when they just hang around waiting for a tip?

As you walk to the front door you could say something like, “Well, we’re all done here. I’ll be sure to tell the boss you did a great job. Thank you. See ya.”

If they don’t get the hint, you could add, “Do you need me to help you bring your stuff to your car”?

If they STILL don’t get the hint, you could do what a lot of people do when they’re in a situation they want to get away from. Make sure you’re carrying your cell phone in your hand (which you’re probably doing anyway). Then quickly, put the phone to your ear and say. “Oh, hi, yeh, just a minute.” Tell the tip-seeker, “I gotta take this call. Thanks for everything. Bye.”

If they still, still, still don’t get the hint, hang up and call a cop.

Jido

Medical Halacha – Is There Jewish DNA?

Rabbi Yehuda Finchas

Blake entered my office visibly excited. “Rabbi, as far as I know, I’m not Jewish. But out of curiosity, I checked my ancestry on the 23andMe website, and it claims that my lineage includes Jewish heritage. Does that mean I’m Jewish? Can I marry a Jewish girl if 23andMe says I’m Jewish?”

What is DNA Testing?

To answer this question, we need to first discuss DNA testing in general and then focus on genetic ancestry testing. Every person has a unique DNA profile, much like a fingerprint. DNA is found in nearly every cell in the body. In recent years, mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) has become a popular tool for genetic ancestry identification. Mitochondria, the powerhouses of our cells, have their own genetic material, which is passed down exclusively from mother to child. This means mtDNA is inherited along the maternal line and according to halacha it is the mother who determines if the children are Jewish. So, can mtDNA prove you are Jewish?

There are several types of DNA tests. For example, blood tests can detect hereditary diseases such as Tay-Sachs and Cystic Fibrosis, identifying whether a person carries the genes linked to these conditions. DNA testing is also used in forensic science to identify human remains, ensure that all body parts are buried together, and establish identity. Additionally, genetic testing can be used to establish paternity and confirm direct biological relationships. These tests are highly accurate.

Genetic ancestry testing, however, has several limitations. While general DNA tests can accurately determine close family relationships (e.g., parents, siblings, cousins), any connections beyond that are based on probability and statistical estimates.

Jewish DNA?

There is no specific “Jewish DNA.” However, some researchers have found that certain mtDNA haplogroups – groups of related mtDNA sequences – are more common among Jewish populations than in the general population. For example, Nephrologist Karl Skorecki and researcher in molecular genetics Behar write, “At least 40 percent of the Ashkenazi population carry one of four unique forms of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA)…” In other words, over 3 million Ashkenazi Jews are descendants of four women who were among the founders of the Ashkenazi population. These haplotypes are more prevalent in Ashkenazi Jews and rarely found in Jews of other origins or in non-Jews.

However, these conclusions have been contested as statistically problematic. Since Jewish people make up less than 1 out of 500 people globally, even if a haplotype is much more common in Ashkenazi Jews – say, 100 times more prevalent than in non-Jews – there is still a higher chance that a person with that haplotype is a non-Jewish outlier rather than a Jewish individual.

Other research challenges Skorecki and Behar’s findings. For instance, Professor Raphael Falk from the Hebrew University (2015) concluded that, “genetic markers cannot determine Jewish descent.” Similarly, in 2016, Dr. Eran Elhaik stated that it is impossible to prove Jewish descent using genetic markers and highlighted several issues with current research. Tofanelli’s research in 2014 also pointed out the limitations of using haplotype motifs as reliable indicators of Jewish ancestry.

In Conclusion

In conclusion, there is no clear scientific evidence that one can rely on to determine Jewish descent based purely on genetic testing. Mitochondrial DNA cannot definitively prove that a person is Jewish. While Jewish populations may share certain genetic markers, there is no unique DNA sequence that definitively establishes Jewish ancestry. Therefore, in practice – halacha l’maaseh – Blake cannot rely on his DNA test to prove his Jewishness. If he wishes to marry a Jewish girl, he must establish that his mother or grandmother is Jewish according to halacha.

Jewish people possess special spiritual traits, as reflected in the Gemara (Yevamot 78b), which lists three defining characteristics of the Jewish people: they are merciful, humble, and engage in acts of loving-kindness. The Gemara teaches that anyone who embodies these three traits is truly deserving of our companionship. These are so to speak the spiritual genes of the Jewish people.

Rabbi Yehuda Finchas is a recognized expert, lecturer, and author on Medical Halacha. He is the head of the Torat Habayit Medical Halacha Institute. His latest book is “Brain Death in Halacha and the Tower of Babel Syndrome.” To contact Rabbi Finchas, please email rabbi@torathabayit.com.

Riddles – January 2025

RIDDLE: What Am I?

Submitted by: Leon G.

I was known to philosophers a thousand years ago.  I have numbers all in a line, and I can tell you if rain will turn to snow. What am I?

Last Month’s Riddle: Unique Number

The number 8,549,176,320 is a unique number. What is so special about it?

Solution: This is the only number that includes all the digits arranged in alphabetical order!

Solved by: Eli Bareket, Yehezkel Alfi,  Ralph Sutton, Jake Shalom, Al Gindi, Sammy Gabbay, Norman Esses, Aaron Vilinsky, Raymond Betesh, Perry Halawani,  Alice Sardar, David Maimon, Jacob Ayal, Richie Ayal, and The Shmulster.

JUNIOR RIDDLE:  Time to Chime

Submitted by: Leslie N.

A clock chimes 5 times in 4 seconds. How many times will it chime in 10 seconds?

Last Month’s Junior Riddle: Escape Plan

A man is trapped in a room with only two possible exits. Through the first door is a room with an enormous magnifying glass causing the blazing hot sun to instantly burn anything that enters. Through the second door there is a fire-breathing dragon. How does the man escape?

Solution: Leave through the first door at night when the sun is down.

Solved by: Yossi B., Isaac Ayal, Jake Shalom, Big Mike, Sammy Gabbay, Norman Esses, Solly Dahan, Aaron Vilinsky, Raymond Betesh,  Perry Halawani, Mayer Cohen, Chehebar Franco Family, David Maimon, The Big Cheese, and Jacob Ayal.

From The Files of the Mitzvah Man Hesed Stories – The Very First Case

Pnina Souid

The Mitzvah Man relates that when he was first starting out, he learned the valuable lessons of strength in numbers and recognizing his limits. It started with one phone call.

A Call for Help

One summer day thirteen years ago the Mitzvah Man received a call from the friend of a woman who was blind who we’ll call Sarah. Sarah had seen an advertisement for the Mitzvah Man’s offer to do hesed. She had been invited to her friend’s 90th birthday party, and was looking for a ride. However, the Mitzvah man had to decline, as he was not in Brooklyn for the summer.

Sarah was very disappointed, but the Mitzvah Man offered to help her when he returned to Brooklyn after the summer, saying he would be happy to help her with her errands when he was back.

Sarah was delighted at the offer and started listing off her needs. “I need someone to make phone calls for me, order groceries to be delivered, make doctor appointments and take me there, among other things. Besides being blind, I have no family.”

The Mitzvah Man respectfully inquired as to why Sarah did not have a companion or home health aide. She had tried several! But none had worked out for her. The Mitzvah Man felt a little overwhelmed by the jobs she might have for him, but he promised that when he was back in Brooklyn, he would see how he could help her.

True to his word, after the Mitzvah Man was back in Brooklyn he went to pay Sarah a visit. She was living alone on the third floor of a three-story walkup in Coney Island. The building belonged to a yeshiva that occupied the first two floors.

Sarah was so happy to welcome the Mitzvah Man into her home. She knew just where everything was. She had been a true baalat hesed when she was able to see, giving tzedaka and helping people in need. Plaques covered her walls. Although she was blind she knew exactly which plaque was which and she proudly showed the Mitzvah Man a number of laudatory articles. She was familiar with each one was and clearly remembered what was written about her.

The Aha! Moment – Recruit Others

The Mitzvah Man pondered how he could possibly help Sarah with all of her needs. He was working alone, with no team of volunteers to help him. He realized that he could do so much more with the assistance of others. He offered a tefilla to Hashem asking for guidance. The choice was to continue working alone or to recruit other volunteers to join him. He felt Hashem telling him that the thing to do was to take his hesed work to the next level.

To accomplish that goal he placed an ad in the paper to create the Mitzvah Man organization. 20 volunteers answered the call.

Sarah now had a team of volunteers to help her. Team members got to work to make her phone calls and to set up her doctor appointments, and they visited her, as well. One of the volunteers accompanied Sarah to a wedding, helped her on to the dance floor, and danced with her. After the wedding she took Sarah home.

There were many phone calls to be made. A volunteer suggested getting Sarah a special phone that could be programmed, allowing Sarah to make calls just by speaking into the phone.

Another volunteer took it upon herself to take Sarah out for walks on nice days

One night Sarah experienced chest pains. She was able to reach Hatzalah on her voice activated phone. Hatzalah volunteers quickly came and transported her to the hospital. She was having a heart attack. The phone saved her life. Sarah lived another five years.

The modest beginning with 20 volunteers has blossomed into a vibrant team of 3,800 volunteers who answer the call to do hesed in Brooklyn, Manhattan, Deal, and Long Branch, New Jersey.